keyval 和 pgfkeys 能产生相同的结果吗?

keyval 和 pgfkeys 能产生相同的结果吗?

我花了大约五个小时(!)学习如何创建带有键值的命令?(和其他资源)并试图理解如何实现键值,这非常令人困惑。我编写了一个本质上很简单的测试用例(至少对这里的大多数人来说)并且有一些我无法解释的不一致之处。

这是使用 的 MWE keyval

% !TEX TS-program = lualatexmk
% !TEX encoding = UTF-8 Unicode

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{keyval}

\makeatletter
% Key definitions
\define@key{sayhello}{towhom}{\def\sh@towhom{#1}}
% Key defaults
\setkeys{sayhello}{towhom=Michael}
% Define the command that uses the key
\newcommand{\sayhello}[2][]{%
  %\begingroup% localizes the new settings w/o calling the defaults
  \setkeys{sayhello}{towhom=Michael} % Reset defaults w/o localizing
  \setkeys{sayhello}{#1} % Set new keys
  Say hello to \sh@towhom\ #2.
  %\endgroup%
}%
\makeatother
\begin{document}
\sayhello{tomorrow}

%\sayhello[towhom]{today} % throws no value specified for towhom

\sayhello[towhom=Jill]{tomorrow}

%\sayhello[towhom]{today} % throws no value specified for towhom

\sayhello[towhom=Joe]{tomorrow}

%\sayhello[towhom]{tomorrow} % throws no value specified for towhom

\sayhello{today}
\end{document}

这里是使用 的 MWE pgfkeys

% !TEX TS-program = lualatexmk
% !TEX encoding = UTF-8 Unicode

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{pgfkeys}

\pgfkeys{%
  /sayhello/.is family, /sayhello,
  towhom/.default=Michael,
  towhom/.store in=\sayto
}%

\newcommand*{\sayhello}[2][]{%
  \pgfkeys{/sayhello,#1}
  Say hello to \sayto\ #2.
}%
\begin{document}
%\sayhello{tomorrow} % throws undefined control sequence

\sayhello[towhom]{today}

\sayhello[towhom=Jill]{tomorrow}

\sayhello[towhom]{today}

\sayhello[towhom=Joe]{tomorrow}

\sayhello[towhom]{tomorrow}

\sayhello{today} % works perfectly
\end{document}

我希望这两种实现都能得到相同的结果。但事实并非如此。keyval似乎不喜欢指定没有值的键。pgfkeys当没有给出任何选项时,其行为不一致,但当keyval没有给出任何选项时,其行为完美。我的例子编码错误了吗?不一致的行为是预期的行为吗?我完全糊涂了。

答案1

您混淆了初始值和默认值。如果您使用键而不提供值,则使用第二个值。除此之外,如果您使用命令来存储键值,最好先用 定义它\newcommand,因为这将避免您覆盖现有命令。

我个人觉得这pgfkeys更令人困惑,因为使用相同的命令来定义和设置键,并且理解某些处理程序的行为并不总是那么容易,例如pgfkeys 密钥处理程序 .get 和 .store 起什么作用?

\documentclass{article}
\usepackage{keyval}

\makeatletter
\newcommand\sh@towhom{}
\define@key{sayhello}{towhom}[Default]{\def\sh@towhom{#1}}
\setkeys{sayhello}{towhom=Initial}
\newcommand{\sayhello}[2][]{%
  \begingroup  
  \setkeys{sayhello}{#1} % Set new keys
   keyval, say hello to \sh@towhom\ #2.
  \endgroup%
}%
\makeatother

\usepackage{pgfkeys}

\newcommand\sayto{}
\pgfkeys{%
  /sayhello/.is family, /sayhello,
  towhom/.store in=\sayto,
  towhom/.default=Default,
  towhom = Initial,
}%

\newcommand*{\sayhellopgf}[2][]{%
  \begingroup
  \pgfkeys{/sayhello,#1}%
   pgfkeys, say hello to \sayto\ #2.
  \endgroup 
}%

\ExplSyntaxOn
\tl_new:N \l_sayhello_towhom_tl
\keys_define:nn {sayhello}
 {
  towhom .tl_set:N = \l_sayhello_towhom_tl,
  towhom .initial:n = Initial,
  towhom .default:n = Default 
 }
 
\NewDocumentCommand\sayhelloexpl{O{}m}
 {
  \group_begin:
  \keys_set:nn{sayhello}{#1}
  l3keys,~say~hello~to~\l_sayhello_towhom_tl\c_space_tl#2
  \group_end:
 }
 
  
\ExplSyntaxOff
\begin{document}
\sayhello{tomorrow}

\sayhello[towhom]{today} 

\sayhello[towhom=Jill]{tomorrow}

\sayhello[towhom]{today} 

\sayhello[towhom=Joe]{tomorrow}

\sayhello[towhom]{tomorrow} 

\sayhello{today}

\sayhellopgf{tomorrow}

\sayhellopgf[towhom]{today} 

\sayhellopgf[towhom=Jill]{tomorrow}

\sayhellopgf[towhom]{today} 

\sayhellopgf[towhom=Joe]{tomorrow}

\sayhellopgf[towhom]{tomorrow} 

\sayhellopgf{today}


\sayhelloexpl{tomorrow}

\sayhelloexpl[towhom]{today} 

\sayhelloexpl[towhom=Jill]{tomorrow}

\sayhelloexpl[towhom]{today} 

\sayhelloexpl[towhom=Joe]{tomorrow}

\sayhelloexpl[towhom]{tomorrow} 

\sayhelloexpl{today}
\end{document}

在此处输入图片描述

相关内容